the film
Commentaries and editorials

Hot Metal Market

by Drew DeSilver, Seattle Times business reporter
Seattle Times - March 20, 2005

Metal Prices Surge Nearly all of the 215,000 miles of rebar that rolls out of Nucor's West Seattle steel mill each year is used within several hundred miles of the plant, helping support structures ranging from Seattle's Qwest Field to the Tacoma Narrows bridge.

Most of the junked autos, old refrigerators, railcars and other scrap that meet their doom inside Nucor Seattle's 3,200-degree furnace come from the same region.

So, with the Northwest economy firmly in recovery mode and rebar prices almost twice what they were when Nucor bought the plant just over two years ago, these should be gravy days for Doug Jellison, general manager of Nucor Seattle.

And yet, Jellison finds his thoughts turning west about 5,432 miles west, to Beijing, China. Because no matter how self-sufficient Nucor Seattle may appear, what happens in booming China has a very real impact on how much steel Jellison's mill makes and how profitably he can sell it.

"The market driver is China, no question about it," he said.

(Ellen M. Banner photo) The lid on the electric arc furnace at Nucor steel mill is lifted up so more metal can be dropped into the furnace to be melted. Sixty thousand tons of scrap metal are melted there each month. Demand from China and the economic recovery in the United States have re-energized some Pacific Northwest metal industries. Insatiable demand from China, along with the recovering U.S. economy, has boosted prices for raw industrial commodities across the board. As a result, several Pacific Northwest metals industries steel making, aluminum smelting, hard-rock mining for silver, lead and zinc have rebounded from their near-comatose state of just a few years ago.

But as other industries have learned, China can be a competitor as well as a customer. In recent months, China has begun exporting spare rebar to the United States, pushing down prices and prompting production cutbacks at producers such as the Nucor Seattle plant. In aluminum, China's production capacity nearly tripled between 1995 and 2003, reshaping the global market.

Prices for many metals remain at or near historic highs, despite some recent slippage. But high prices alone can't guarantee healthy metals industries, in the Northwest or anywhere else. Steel mills and aluminum smelters require lots of cheap electricity, and the Bush administration's recent proposal to raise Bonneville Power Administration rates sent industry and government leaders scrambling to block it. And if U.S. industrial production falters, so will metals demand.

Role in Northwest history

Though largely overshadowed by timber, aerospace and, most recently, high technology, metals precious and otherwise have played key roles in Northwest history.

A series of gold rushes in the 1860s lured miners to what would become Idaho; the Panhandle's Silver Valley has produced billions of dollars worth of silver, lead, zinc and other metals.

The West Seattle mill now owned by Nucor will mark its 100th anniversary in May; it was started by William Pigott, who also founded Paccar. After the Columbia River dams were built, aluminum smelters attracted by rock-bottom electricity sprouted across the region.

More recently, though, a combination of slack demand, low commodity prices and higher electricity rates combined to dull metals' luster. Mines and smelters shut down; steel was replaced by silicon in the public consciousness.

But the past 18 months have been a boom time for metal producers. On the London Metals Exchange, aluminum futures are up 39.5 percent since October 2003; zinc is up 68.5 percent, lead 74.4 percent and copper a whopping 82 percent.

After scrap metal is melted down, the molten steel is distributed into four separate streams, which then go into copper molds. Manufactured steel products have shared in the boom. According to Purchasing, a Newton, Mass.-based journal for industrial-purchasing managers, the spot price for hot-rolled steel sheet an industry benchmark has more than doubled since October 2003, from $295 a ton to $600.

Whatever the metal, the same basic factors are behind the double-digit increases, said Tom Stundza, Purchasing's executive editor: a reviving U.S. economy demanding the same goods that China already had been eagerly snapping up.

"China's economy has been on this insane building boom," Stundza said. "They're trying to electrify the country, so they've been sucking up every bit of copper they can get their hands on.

"They've got an Olympics coming up in 2008, and they're trying to industrialize their country so that when people come to visit they don't see a Third World country."

Metals producers in the Northwest have responded to the higher prices:

Continued demand key

Much of all this activity, though, depends on continued demand to absorb the supplies of new metals and support current price levels.

For example, China is expected to consume about 350 million tons of steel this year, Nucor's Jellison said more than a third of the world supply. But since last summer, China's leaders also have been trying to rein in the country's galloping economy.

(Thomas James Hurst photo) Most of the junked autos, old refrigerators, railcars and other scrap that meet their doom at Nucor come from the region. If the consumption forecast is off by less than 10 percent, Jellison noted, "that means another 30 million tons of steel are heading to the United States, and that can make the difference between making money and losing money."

Spot prices for various steel products, which started rising in late 2003, peaked last summer and have been mostly flat to slightly lower since, according to Purchasing data. Aluminum, lead and other industrial metals have followed similar patterns, though zinc is still rising strongly.

And then there's the prospect of competing against the Chinese industrial colossus, rather than merely supplying it.

Over the past several years, China has used a good share of its steel imports to build steel mills of its own; it is now the world's largest steel producer, churning out about 270 million tons last year.

But while China still is buying all the steel sheet and plate it can find, it began exporting other products late last year. In November and December, Purchasing's Stundza said, China exported a million tons of steel mostly rebar and light structural steel.

The impact was felt quickly: As West Coast supplies rose, rebar prices which peaked at about $550 a ton in August began to drop; they run about $470 a ton today. Nucor Seattle cut back output: In the fourth quarter of 2004, the plant's total tonnage was 28 percent below the level set the first nine months of the year.

"A year ago, everything was in short supply and everything was going up in price," Jellison said. "Now it's a lot more variable some products, like plate, are still in short supply, but less so for rebar. All the capacity they built is catching up with them."

Another issue for minimills such as Nucor's is the rising price of scrap steel.

Two years ago, a ton of scrap cost about $139; today, that ton fetches $305 (though prices have dropped by nearly a third since their peak in November). A big reason: Increased demand from China for the world's junked cars and broken machinery as feedstock for all those new minimills.

Strong aluminum market

Chinese demand along with an upturn in the aerospace, commercial vehicle and construction industries has also contributed to the runup in prices of aluminum and alumina, the intermediate product that is smelted into finished aluminum.

As China's construction boom has absorbed much of the world's available aluminum, the country's own production has more than tripled from 1.26 million metric tons in 1993 to 6.6 million metric tons last year, according to James F. King, a British industrial-metals consultant.

China's imports soar

Over the same period, China's alumina imports have soared from 951,000 metric tons to 6.3 million metric tons.

The stronger aluminum market, along with a new labor contract and guaranteed power from the Chelan County Public Utility District, helped Alcoa decide to restart its Wenatchee smelter. The plant, which employs 400 workers, will produce 85,000 metric tons of aluminum this year.

But the Northwest's aluminum industry what's left of it, anyway remains vulnerable to energy prices. Soaring energy costs earlier this decade combined with falling demand during the recession to shut down almost all the region's smelters; only three, in Wenatchee, Ferndale and Columbia Falls, Mont., are operating today, all at reduced capacity.

Alcoa, like Nucor, is watching carefully the Bush administration's proposal for BPA to sell its hydropower at close to market rates. A recent report by the Northwest Power and Conservation Council estimated that such a move would raise electricity bills by 39 percent; Northwest politicians from across the political spectrum have moved to block Bush's plan.

But Alcoa isn't putting all, or even most, of its eggs in BPA's basket. In July the Pittsburgh-based company broke ground on a smelter in Iceland, its first new smelter in two decades. When completed in 2007, the plant will be able to produce 322,000 metric tons of aluminum a year.

Central to the decision to build in Iceland, the company says, was an agreement by the national electricity company to build a hydropower project to supply cheap power to the smelter for the next 40 years.

"When you make aluminum, you need long-term, competitively priced energy," company spokesman Kevin Lowery said. "At the end of the day, aluminum is a commodity, and you need to make it in the lowest cost way possible."

Drew DeSilver, Seattle Times business reporter
Hot Metal Market
Seattle Times, March 20, 2005

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation