|
the film forum library tutorial contact |
|
WSDOT Updates CO2 Emission Estimates
by Eric Barker
|
Previous story on the open house meeting, mistakenly said that
each of the scenarios would increase carbon dioxide emissions.
The Washington State Department of Transportation has updated the estimated carbon dioxide emissions associated with various road and rail infrastructure projects that could be implemented if the four lower Snake River dams are breached.
Under the new calculations to address an error, emissions could rise under some of the scenarios that the agency will present in a report to the Washington Legislature later this year and fall under others. All of the changes are modest compared to the status quo and each of the scenarios would carry price tags that reach into the billions.
The agency held an open house in Clarkston Oct. 8 to share the general conclusion of the report that examines how the transportation network in eastern Washington could be augmented if the four lower Snake River dams are eventually removed as part of an effort to restore threatened and endangered salmon and steelhead.
The scenarios include upgrading the existing rail line that follows the Snake River between Lewiston and Pasco with new high-capacity grain terminals at Lewiston, the Port of Wilma and Central Ferry. It would cost $4 to $5.03 billion to build, with annual shipping costs of $323 million and 230,400 tons of annual carbon dioxide emissions.
Another scenario contemplates short-line railroads absorbing the wheat shipped by barge with new grain terminals at Lewiston and Wilma and pieces of new rail line. It would cost $4.4 to $5.9 billion, with annual shipping costs of $316 million and 215,800 tons of annual emissions.
Both of those scenarios would amount to an increase in emissions over the status quo calculation of 209,700 tons.
Two other scenarios would reduce emissions. The first includes short-line buildout, upgrades to the existing line along the river with the new terminals and infrastructure to increase rail shipping via Class I railroads -- Union Pacific and BNSF Railway. It would cost $4.4 to $5.8 billion with annual shipping costs of $310.4 million and 203,000 tons of carbon emissions.
A final scenario would build new infrastructure to transfer all the river traffic to Class I railroads. It would cost $3.8 to $5 billion, with annual shipping costs of $322.7 million and 207,200 tons of carbon emissions.
If the dams were breached and the road and highway system were used to absorb the wheat that once moved by rail, carbon emissions would rise to 453,700 tons per year. Each of the calculations is modeled through 2045 in the report.
A Lewiston Tribune story on the open house meeting, mistakenly said that each of the scenarios presented at the meeting would increase carbon dioxide emissions.
In 2023, former President Joe Biden reached a deal with lower Columbia River Indian Tribes including the Nez Perce, along with conservation groups and the states of Oregon and Washington that was expected to bring more than $1 billion in federal investments to help recover wild fish in the Snake and Columbia rivers in exchange for a five- to 10-year pause in litigation. While it did not call for the four lower Snake River dams to be breached, it funded studies into the best ways to replace barging, power generation and irrigation made possible by the dams and was largely seen as a precursor to future breaching.
President Donald Trump killed the deal about six months into his second term. However, the Washington Legislature had previously provided funding to the Washington State Department of Transportation to study impacts related to dam breaching, including $5 million to examine how the loss of river transportation could be mitigated.
Related Pages:
New Study says Grain Transportation Possible Without Snake River Dams But at a Price by Eric Barker, Moscow-Pullman Daily News, 10/8/26
Lewiston Looking to Invest in Infrastructure by Elaine Williams
Lewiston Tribune, 2/14/25
Study: Breaching Wouldn't Affect River's Water Withdrawal by Eric Barker, Lewiston Tribune, 2/6/25
Study Looks at Water Delivery in a Post-Dam Snake River by Eric Barker, Moscow-Pullman Daily News, 1/26/25
Corps, State to Partner in Dam Studies by Eric Barker, Lewiston Tribune, 11/5/24
learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum