|
the film forum library tutorial contact |
|
New Study says Grain Transportation Possible
by Eric Barker
|
The agency hosted an open house meeting at the
Clarkston High School Library Wednesday evening
If the lower Snake River dams are breached to save threatened and endangered salmon, upgrades to rail and road networks could absorb grain shipments that now move by tug and barge.
But according to a pending Washington State Department of Transportation study, it would cost billions of dollars, raise shipping costs for farmers and release more carbon dioxide into the atmosphere.
The agency hosted an open house meeting at the Clarkston High School Library Wednesday evening to share the results of its three-year study that will be finalized into a report and presented to the Washington Legislature in December.
It presents a series of scenarios with differing solutions to the loss of tug-and-barge transportation and the associated costs of building out infrastructure, the increased price growers will pay to get the crops to market and the carbon footprint of doing so. Each one is designed to fully handle the existing river traffic and each starts with the same baseline data so they can be fairly compared.
"They all solve the problem but they all have a cost to the farmers and a cost to the environment to do it," said Jim Mahugh, the lead author of the study for the transportation department.
The scenarios include upgrading the existing rail line that follows the Snake River between Lewiston and Pasco with new high-capacity grain terminals at Lewiston, the Port of Wilma and Central Ferry. It would cost $4 to $5.03 billion to build, with annual shipping costs of $323 million and 224,000 tons of annual carbon dioxide emissions.
Another scenario contemplates short-line railroads absorbing the river transportation with terminals at Lewiston and Wilma and pieces of new rail line. It would cost $4.4 to $5.9 billion, with annual shipping costs of $316 million and 239,000 tons of annual emissions.
A "do everything" scenario includes shortline buildout, upgrades to the existing line along the river with the new terminals and infrastructure to increase rail shipping via Class I railroads -- Union Pacific and BNSF Railway. It would cost $4.4 to $5.8 billion with annual shipping costs of $310.4 million and 231,000 tons of carbon emissions.
A final scenario would build new infrastructure to transfer all the river traffic to Class I railroads. It would cost $3.8 to $5 billion, with annual shipping costs of $322.7 million and 205,000 tons of carbon emissions.
For comparison, if the dams were breached and nothing else was done, the road and highway system would absorb most of the grain now shipped by barge. Road maintenance in Washington would cost $3.8 to $5.1 billion through 2045, annual shipping costs would be $332 million and 394,000 tons of carbon would be released. And with the system as it exists now shippers pay about $256.8 million and release 253,000 tons of carbon dioxide. The study does not include the cost to maintain the dams and associated locks that make river transportation possible.
The department was tasked by the Washington Legislature to compile the study.
"We as the department are neutral. We are not asked by the department to pick a preferred alternative," said Mahugh.
Port of Lewiston manager Scott Corbitt complimented the department for taking on a Hurculean task but said because the job was so big and difficult, the study has holes. He said it fails to contemplate that the increased shipping costs will be too much for some growers to bear and that big Class I rail lines prioritize other goods over wheat and would have little interest in taking on more of it without dramatic price increases. He said the study is designed to present Congress with viable alternatives to the dams but misses the mark.
"Getting a good picture for Congress to make a fully informed decision -- in our opinion, this study falls far, far short in that, in fact, it is likely misleading."
Stephen Pfeiffer, wild fish and hydropower policy manager for Idaho Rivers United, said the study shows there are viable alternatives that include fewer trucks on roads and highways. He also said there are political solutions, such as shipping support that was part of Idaho Congressman Mike Simpson’s $33 billion plan to breach the four dams and mitigate affected communities and industries, that the study wasn’t able to contemplate.
"What groups like mine really try to emphasize is that, you know, we don’t support taking up dams, without some sort of price support in place, whether it’s along lines of Simpson’s plan or whatever thing that the farming community comes up with themselves," he said.
In 2023, former president Joe Biden reached a deal with lower Columbia River Indian Tribes including the Nez Perce, along with conservation groups and the states of Oregon and Washington that was expected to bring more than $1 billion in federal investments to help recover wild fish in the Snake and Columbia rivers in exchange for a five- to 10-year pause in litigation. While it did not call for the four lower Snake River dams to be breached, it funded studies into the best ways to replace barging, power generation and irrigation made possible by the dams and was largely seen as a precursor to future breaching.
President Donald Trump killed the deal about six months into his second term. However, the Washington Legislature had previously provided funding to the Washington State Department of Transportation to study impacts related to dam breaching, including $5 million to examine how the loss of river transportation could be mitigated.
Related Pages:
Lewiston Looking to Invest in Infrastructure by Elaine Williams
Lewiston Tribune, 2/14/25
Study: Breaching Wouldn't Affect River's Water Withdrawal by Eric Barker, Lewiston Tribune, 2/6/25
Study Looks at Water Delivery in a Post-Dam Snake River by Eric Barker, Moscow-Pullman Daily News, 1/26/25
Corps, State to Partner in Dam Studies by Eric Barker, Lewiston Tribune, 11/5/24
learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum